Impact evaluation of irrigation on rural household welfare. Choosing appropriate designs and methods for impact evaluation. Kirindi oya irrigation and settlement project project. Assessment of arsenic in rice growing areas of pakistan april2014 view pdf. Irrigation scheduling web sites and software sources are listed in appendix f. Carrying out such analysis requires analysis of data collected at the appropriate time and places, often using statistical. The interview will take about 90 minutes and we will ask questions to you or from other adults in the household who may be the most knowledgeable about particular topics. This publication is a working revision of landscape irrigation system evaluation and scheduling for southern california, written by david a. Hydrological, or direct, effects of doing this include reduction in downstream river flow, increased evaporation in the irrigated area, increased level in the water table as groundwater recharge in the area is increased and flow increased in the irrigated area. The baseline and follow ups surveys are part of an impact evaluation of the land husbandry, water harvesting and hillside irrigation lwh project in rwanda.
Congratulations to the selected winners of the best paper award 2019. Impact evaluation of the irrigation infrastructure activity. Toolbox material video level border irrigation evaluation, module 910, irrigation training series, nrcs. Impact evaluation can help bring the types of positive feedback that have been routinely used in product development in the private sector. Impact on crop diversity, cropping intensity, and crop productivity 8 c. This measurement of the irrigation event is known as an evaluation. To collect the required data several methods like interview schedule, focus group discussions and key informant interviews were used.
Landscape irrigation system evaluation and management. Under the commission from jica, we conducted a fourround household survey from 2009 to 2010 to estimate the impacts of kaeng khoiban mo kkbm pump. An impact evaluation of indias second and third andhra. Jica has been working on promoting the utilization of impact evaluation methods. Water sources include dams, bores, wells, rivers, town water, channels and recycled water. Analysis of data from the 2008 usda farm and ranch irrigation survey shows that the average energy use for irrigating crops in nebraska alone would be equivalent to about 340 million. Debates in impact evaluation impact evaluation is the counterfactual analysis of the impact of an intervention on final welfare outcomes. Request pdf stochastic impact evaluation of an irrigation development intervention in northern ethiopia irrigation plays a significant role in achieving food and nutrition security in dry regions. Impact evaluation of mae lao irrigation improvement project. This report evaluates the impacts of irrigation infrastructure rehabilitation implemented under the millennium challenge corporations compact with the republic of armenia.
Impact evaluation seeks to determine the longer term results that are generated by policy decisions, often through interventions, projects or programmes. Dripirrigation systems for small conventional vegetable. Among the areas for detailed examination are crop and lives. Sprinkler irrigation in semiarid areas of rajasthan. Evaluating the impact on farm households a multicomponent. Impact evaluation study shallow tubewell irrigation in nepal. Impact evaluation of existing irrigation and agronomic practices on irrigation efficiency and crop yields in northern areas of pakistan data collection details hunza name of valley danyor name of village gilgit river subbasin name of river basinsub basin a.
A summary of the evaluation results will be presented. Terms of reference for a baseline survey for an agricultural water management project rn3. Accordingly, a simplified approach was adopted using the leopold matrix method. Pdf is irrigation rehabilitation good for poor farmers. Impact evaluation of a large irrigation project article pdf available in water international 1 january 1988 with 28 reads how we measure reads. This study was conducted at boloso sore district of southern ethiopia. Impact evaluation is the main means for empirically testing what actually happens when interventions are implemented. Total of 826 households were selected and interviewed. To reduce nonpoint source pollution caused by leaching and runoff. An impact evaluation of indias second and third andhra pradesh irrigation projects a case of poverty reduction with low economic returns world bank independent evaluation group. Kirindi oya irrigation and settlement project project impact evaluation study draet final report exect tive summary the koisp project impact evaluation study was a collaborative research effort between the international irrigation management institute iimi and. This book further highlights that including external benefits environmental and health in economic.
Kurunegala rural development project credit 891ce second rural development project credit 1079ce attached is an impact evaluation report ier on two rural development projects in sri lanka. Third, the study will analyze household survey data to evaluate project impact using. Outcomes versus output, input, activities and impact inputs. Additional bmps involving drip irrigation include bmp 26 soil testingsoil ph, bmp 36 water supply and bmp 40 irrigation scheduling. Best management practices for irrigation management.
Impact evaluation of the irrigation infrastructure. Methodologies adopted in quantifying the outcomes and impacts of irrigation 10 f. Irrigation and drainage is the official journal of the international commission on the irrigation and drainage icid. Impact evaluation of irrigation on rural household welfare munich. Irrigation is a key part of successful root canal treatment. One key challenge of evaluating the impact of an irrigation project is the. It has several important functions, which may vary according to the irrigant used. These indicators could be adopted by adb in future irrigation project designs.
The impact of irrigation water wet season by panel analysis. The ida credits were approved in fy79 and fy81, and closed in fy86 and fy90. The ministry of agriculture in rwanda minagri is implementing the lwh project with technical assistance from the world bank. Is irrigation rehabilitation good for poor farmers. Impact evaluation report on pasak irrigation projectthailand. Impact evaluation of community groundwater irrigation sector. This information is important to know as it will tell us how to improve the success of projects meant to support farmers such as yourself. Guidance for the terms of reference for impact evaluations. Steps i and 2 are pre evaluation procedures and are site specific.
Pdf an evaluation of cgiar centers impact assessment work. March 15, 2012 seiro ito satoshi ohira kazunari tsukada abstract underthecommissionfromjica,weconductedafourroundhouseholdsurvey from 2009 to 2010 to estimate the impacts of kaeng khoiban mo kkbm pump irrigation scheme. Overall impact evaluation of the lwh program is an example of how an implementation team can work to learn lessons on program impacts through a nonexperimental impact evaluation design that relies on natural constraints related to program design and delivery. Aug 09, 2018 this data contains baseline information for the impact evaluation of this activity. Munich personal repec archive impact evaluation of irrigation on rural household welfare. It also includes monitoring of the wider context, such as early warning monitoring, or monitoring of socioeconomic trends. Monitoring and evaluation of irrigation projects has been a neglected subject, but must play a more important role in the future if the irrigation man agement process is to be improved. This approach was then used to assess and weigh the impact of various. Gcc 2016 and the present policy brief, solar pumping for irrigation.
Monitoring and evaluation of irrigation projects by asit k. Ii first quarter progress report kirindi oya irrigation. The projects were conducted without the aim or the tools for a full. Impact evaluations in agriculture independent evaluation group.
Irrigation water quality department of primary industries. Oeds manual on evaluation guidelines and practices. Rice farmers in odisha, india, are subject to flooding on an annual basis. With this in mind, economic valuation of wastewater therefore identifies economic benefits for municipalities associated with wastewater treatment. Treatment groups involve households with farmers who belong to fbos within the geographic perimeters of the newrenovated irrigation schemes. Kirindi oya irrigation and settlement project project impact. Impact, maintenance, and sustainability of irrigation impact. Outdoor irrigation constitutes about 60 percent or more of water. Therefore, knowledge of irrigation water quality is critical to understanding what management changes are necessary for longterm productivity. The choice of methods and designs for impact evaluation of policies and.
This project impact evaluation study bas covered a wide range of topics for detailed impact assessment. An application to mekabo scheme in tigray, ethiopia order to assess the environmental impact of a typical ssi scheme. The drip method of irrigation has been found to have a significant impact on resources saving, cost of cultivation, yield of crops and farm profitability. A case study in the karacabey irrigation scheme in turkey article pdf available in african journal of agricultural research 42. Impact evaluation of mae lao irrigation improvement.
The study of the assessment of the benefits and the evaluation of the impact of the kirindi oya irrigation and settlement project koisp is being carried out under two project impact evaluation study agreements, dated 29 december 1993, between the director of irrigation, department of irrigation, colombo for and on behalf of the. Farm water comes from a number of different sources and so its quality varies. Irrigation system maintenance and evaluation, and bmp 47 plasticulture farming. Impact evaluation of existing irrigation and agronomic practies on irrigation efficiency and crop yields in northern areas of pakistan view pdf. Irrigation water quality criteria spectrum technologies. Center pivot irrigation, uniformity, sprinkler packages introduction center pivot irrigation systems are the dominant irrigation system type in use within kansas rogers and aguilar, 2017. Introduction this report presents the evaluation design for the irrigation and water resources management iwrm project in senegal. Level border irrigation evaluation reference material irrigation guide, chapter 9, 15. In parallel to these trends, behavioral economics has increasingly attracted.
The iwrm project is funded as part of the millennium challenge corporation mcc compact with the government of senegal gos. A total of 104 farmers were randomly selected and interviewed by using semistructured questionnaire. The impact assessment and evaluation of the irrigation schemes was carried out through participatory rural appraisal pra, covering farmers, key institutions and local authorities. Evidence from vietnam nguyen, trang and nguyen, cuong 15 february 2016 online at mpra paper no. Toolkit for monitoring and evaluation of agricultural. Choosing designs and methods for impact evaluation 20 3. Impact evaluation and related study on bohol irrigation.
Performance assessment for irrigation water management. Final evaluation of irrigation rehabilitation projects, afghanistan iii. Terms of reference tor for impact evaluation with the main objective of improving the quality of them within cohesion policy programmes. The guidance is primarily meant to apply for evaluations to be carried out by external consultants but can provide also some advice for evaluations done within a national or regional administration. In addition to the use of wellknown impact evaluation techniques, an innovation in this evaluation was the use of location coordinates, landuse data, and information related to water sources to delineate the catchment area for each infrastructure project. Secondly, the afdb idev scoping mission was undertaken from 14 18 january 2019 to consult with key stakeholders in malawi on the proposed impact evaluation of afdb funded irrigation development interventions in malawi. Due to the inherent system complexity and uncertain consequences of irrigation development interventions coupled with limited data availability, deterministic costbenefit analysis can be ineffective in guiding formal decisionmaking. Evaluation and impact assessment of the solar irrigation. Goals sdgs, which include a goal to ensure sustainable water and sanitation for all. Pdf an evaluation of cgiar centers impact assessment. Using impact evaluation to improve policymaking for climate. Impact evaluation of the bohol irrigation project phase 2 in the republic of the philippines pdf 2. Stochastic impact evaluation sie helps to overcome the challenges of evaluating investments in such contexts. He also supports the coordination of impact assessment activities of ifad supported.
Stochastic impact evaluation of an irrigation development. Click here to browse our most recent special issue. This evaluation was conducted by the international rice research institute. Impact of modern irrigation on household production and welfare. Choosing appropriate designs and methods for impact. Water from various sources may be of an unsuitable quality for its intended use for irrigation. Impacts may be positive or negative, intended or unintended, direct or indirect. The evaluation uses a matched comparison group design to assess the effectiveness of rehabilitating irrigation canals, pumping stations, gravity schemes, drainage systems, and other related irrigation activities. The volume shows the results of the impact evaluation of an oda loan project, bohol irrigation project phase 2 in the republic of the philippines. Pasak irrigation project thailand pdf 906kb impact evaluation of third elementary education project in the republic of the philippines pdf 1. Impact of renewables and cooling technologies to 2030 2016, the infocus chapter on desalination in renewable energy market analysis. This includes sprinkler types, nozzle size, pressure, pipe size, installation and system maintenance. For irrigation systems that entirely wet the field overhead or flood systems, irrigation rates are typically expressed in inches.
This paper examines the effect of communal irrigation plants on income and agricultural activities of rural households in vietnam. An irrigation scheme draws water from groundwater, rivers, lakes or overland flow, and distributes it over an area. Bmp implementation requires record keeping see table 3. In its original conception, norc and mca planned to use a rigorous experimental design for the impact evaluation. The objective of this study was to identify determinants of smallscale irrigation use. Final evaluation of the programme for improvement of irrigation. Importance of water in the light of quran and sunnah urdu view pdf. A simplified matrix approach to perform environmental impact. From a randomized control trial to a quasiexperimental design the impact evaluation design for this activity changed radically over the course of the evaluation due to implementation problems. This paper analyses the effect of a set of irrigation rehabilitation projects conducted over the last 10 years in peru. Impact evaluation report on small scale irrigation management. Impaq international, llc page 1 senegal evaluation design report 1. Pdf irrigation development has been conceived as one of the important rural development programme in india where the rainfed agriculture is.
672 856 1375 1295 861 267 492 149 1051 1038 993 593 669 346 1170 1176 1289 8 1520 854 24 361 811 80 491 311 845 1429 681 1010